Calgary Light Rapid Transit Station Design Review
Calgary was an early adopter of the modern light rapid transit (LRT) opening the first leg on May 25 1981 - Edmonton was the first opening in April 1978. By the end of the 20th century, Calgary had one of the highest LRT ridership in North America.
“Prior to designing and building Calgary's LRT system, there were a number of trips made to Europe to tour various LRT systems, most notably in Germany. There the concept of LRT was quite different than what we ended up with in both Edmonton and Calgary. In Europe the stations were very low key, not much more elaborate than a glorified bus stop on a raised platform (much like the 39 Ave Station).
Unfortunately, since much of Calgary's first line was located within the CPR (Canadian Pacific Railway not Canadian Pacific Kansas City) right of way we were governed by CPR design specifications. The one that really influenced station design was that they would not allow any at grade pedestrian crossings of the tracks (both LRT and CPR). Plus, the stations were located only feet away from moving freight trains, so we needed a fairly significant building to allow passengers to get up and over the rail lines plus we had to construct a building that would protect people from the elements and passing trains.
Most of the stations shared identical designs - definitely a cost savings from a design and construction point of view. But, very uninteresting and almost bunker like. Later CPR to relax their no at-grade crossing requirements and all of these stations were modified to provide a more accessible means of access with at grade crossings at the ends of the platforms. When these changes were made, hardly anyone used the station heads which required ascending and descending stairs or using escalators.
From an operational standpoint the simpler European design approach would have saved huge costs to construct and maintain those station heads. Chinook station was rebuilt to a more accessible and low key design when it was discovered that the building was falling apart.” (from former City of Calgary Transit Planner, Neil Mckendrick)
Today Calgary boasts 45 LRT stations and 60 km of LRT tracks. Plans are in place for a huge expansion - Green Line - that will add another 29 stations and 46 kilometres of tracks. One of the unique things about Calgary’s LRT is the Free Fare Zone in the downtown along 7th Ave.
This photo essay will look at the evolution of the design of Calgary’s LRT stations over the past 40+ years - some good and some bad.
While the Calgary Transit divides the current LRT into a Blue and Red Line, I still prefer the terms Northeast, Northwest, West and South lines so that is how I have organized the essay.
FYI: I saved the ugliest one for last.
Northwest Leg
The NW line was scheduled to be built before the NE line but, due to opposition to the routing through Sunnyside the NW construction was delayed and the NE line implementation proceeded. When the routing of the NW line was finally approved, one of the concessions was that the adjacent communities would have input into the design of their stations. This is the reason that the NW stations all have different and unique designs intended to fit into the adjacent communities. Hence the rather low-key designs of the Sunnyside, SAIT, Lions Park and Banff Trail stations.
The location of the line within the Crowchild Trail median brought on the same design requirements as the NE and South lines but, each community had a considerable influence on station designs.
Downtown 7th Avenue Corridor
West Leg
For the West line, all of the stations are unique but follow a 'snow drift' theme with rounded roof lines. The Sunalta station design required a much higher elevated station due to the high clearance requirement for crossing the CPR mainline. We couldn't have a low-level station here since to do so the line would have been like a roller coaster since the tracks had to rise up to cross over Crowchild Tr. The 45 St SW station design was influenced by concerns that trains would block 45 St which is used by the local fire station. A much more expensive but better design station resulted.
Northeast Leg
For the Northeast line from Downtown to Whitehorn all of the stations followed a similar design (grain elevators) which was largely dictated by the location in the middle of major roadways (Memorial Dr and 36 St NE). Again, we had to provide a means of passengers getting up and over these roadways and to provide protection from the adjacent traffic. Elevators were part of these stations to improve accessibility.
When the NE line was extended from Whitehorn to Saddletown the line left 36 St and transitioned to an 'in-community' design along a right of way that had been planned as the communities developed. This was not possible with either the South or NW lines. With the in-community location of the tracks, the stations took on a very low key design - platforms with heated shelters.
South Leg
Last Word
As promised I saved the worst station for last. The 39th Street station is no more than a tiny bus shelter. Enough said.
Learn more at:
Calgary’s 7th Ave Transit Corridor: The Good & Bad
Summary of Calgary’s LRT Stations
(source: City of Calgary)